Chani or Irulan?

[Alexander_Ordos]

I care about the story but in this case imagine Chani and Irulan standing before you ( you sit by your pc  :))

and say the chose is yours... ( offcourse if you imagine how beautyfull they are)...  :-* 8)

Chani or Irulan?

[Acriku]

In Lynch's Dune, Chani was hot!  :-* :-* :-*

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

Irulan in miniserie was great

[jacobdouds]

I thought Irulans in the Miniseries face to to make upy and plastic.

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

It only depend what somebody like. And she looked like Irulan should look

[Alexander_Ordos]

Right Acriku in Lynch's Dune Chani was much more atractive than Irulan but if to read the book descriptions Irulan looks better to me and smarter...

Chani or Irulan?

[IxianMace]

What makes you think Irulan is smarter than Chani? She couldn't even hide her true feelings when someone surpised or shocked her. Just because Chani is a fremen, that doesn't mean that she's not intelligent.  Okay, so the fremen were manipulated by the BG so that the BG could twist them to their ways, but at least the fremen are knowledgeable in the ways of Arrakis.  ;)

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

Irulan wasn`t good Bene Gesserit, she can`t a lot of things that all Bene should know. But she was taught by them and learned many things in Imperial Palace...Chani was intelligent, but more intelligent in emotional meaning. She was able to sacrifice herself.

[IxianMace]

True, true.

[Mahdi]

I'd go with miniseries Irulan... Julie Cox is so...

Sorry, I kinda gapped out for a minute there.

[Colonel_Worf]

I never remember him having to choose. He never gave a second glance to Irulan.

[Mahdi]

I never remember him having to choose. He never gave a second glance to Irulan.

the question was "who would you chose?" not "Who would Paul chose?"

We all know who he picked.

[burseg_candor]

in the miniseries both irulan and chani were hot

so who would you pick from those two?

its a werid question

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

Chani in miniseries looks more like fremen warrior. Irulan in miniseries is beautiful ;D

[jacobdouds]

I thought Chani in the Miniseries didn't look very good. Apart from one moment in the Seicth. *drool drool*

Damn, my keyboard exploded. Then how am I typing this? I'm psychic I am.

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

Chani was Fremen warrior, and she looks more like warrior in miniseries than in Lynch Dune.

[exatreide]

BOTH!  :) ;)

[Alexander_Ordos]

Good at last I turned the topic into right direction ;)

Man when I only think about Irulan....

Chani or Irulan? :)

[Ligic_Tha_Master]

DEHYDRATIN'!!!!!!! ;)

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

Uh. Ligic vote for dehydratin` :)

[Alexander_Ordos]

lol Quite an interesting thought ;) 8) ;D

Chani or Irulan?

[jacobdouds]

I repeat the first moment in the seitch. *"gladrugla"*

Chani, definatly.

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

Chani:

-loved Paul

-gave him children

-was fair, she never would betrey

-was inteligent

Irulan:

-inteligent too

-Bene Gesserit, but it seems not to be very good thing

-loved him (but she was jealous, too jealous)

-had strong personality

[jacobdouds]

Yay, the lightning bolts are back!!. I think Chani was supposed to be more naturaly beutiful, and Irulan, more fancied up.

[Alexander_Ordos]

In which way could a Fremen be inteligent? Perhaps they have good philosophy BUT inteligent means to know:

1. Many languages

2. politics of the Empire

3.  history of the Empire

4. some scientific stuff

5. etc....

P.S All BG know that much...