Chani or Irulan?

[Alexander_Ordos]

I'm currently reading Dune Messiah and now Paul has to make a choice:

Irulan or Chani?

Irulan is a Bene Gesserit and a doughter of an exemperor.

Chani is a fremen but not noble born

I'd choose Irulan - smart, trained pretty 8)

Who'd you choose? ( Don't care about the storyline...)

[Acriku]

Chani baby! The forbidden love makes the fire oh so burn. Irulan is just a tool to get into the bloodline of the Empire and such, nothing more than a bothersome. A concubine in a way.

[Alexander_Ordos]

She has become a tool because of Paul's ignorance...

Anyway for me Irulan rulezz!! Because there's nothing special about Chani...

[Ligic_Tha_Master]

Chani, besides... guess who he picks... ;)

[Acriku]

Chani was not only the one bearing his children, but also his only love. That's pretty special eh?

[Sardauker-Kirov]

Besides. Chani is a real girl and not some blondie like that "Bene Gesserit" Girl.

Besides, Fremen are warrior's!

Long live the fighters!

lol  ;D

[exatreide]

both  ;D

[thomas]

Chani, a women who can back you up in a fight is special ;D

[Timsvs]

well i like chani..she is nice. Irulan is nice too..it's a hard choice...i think both are very good looking too. Probably chani..she is a fighter, irulan is a political figure.

i think i'll let them fight eachother, over me :D

[Gunseng_Harkonnen]

both

[Alexander_Ordos]

Since when are Fremen better fighters than the Bene Gesserit  ::)?

[Sardauker-Kirov]

Since Dune was invented, Besides Fremen are a hardend race and can take some good hits in the stumach. *Ponders if they can survive the blow of a laser in the head*

[quoudam72]

Since when are Fremen better fighters than the Bene Gesserit

[Alexander_Ordos]

Simple exmple from the first Dune - Jessica kicked Stilgra's ass... ;D

[quoudam72]

Yes but after that did Jessica not agree to train (along with Paul) the Fremen in the Bene Gesserit way of battle? The Bene Gesserit function as assassins anyway not battle soliders.

[nemafakei]

Neither; I'd advise Muad'Dib to name Alia's firstborn (and persuade her to get one) heir. Just to annoy the both of them.

[Acriku]

The Bene Gesserit are no match because of population.

[jacobdouds]

Irulan betrayed paul. So who would you choose, someone who will put a knife in your back or someone who would die stopping a knife going into your back.

[Duke_Alex_Atreides]

Someone who would stop that for me of course

[Ligic_Tha_Master]

I believe that was a rethoric question.

[Nefud]

Well of course Chani!  ;D

Irulan's just a political toy, unlike Chani, who's a Fremen desert warrior, mother of 3 and 'the-one-and-only' to Paul Muad-Dib...

And for Fremen vs. BG witches: I think BG would win the match, because they can use the Voice, have prana-bindhu muscles, etc.,etc...

A Fremen without a BG's training is no match for a witch...

[Alexander_Ordos]

True - the fact is that the BG's are better than the Fremen... I'd like to have some of those babies fighting for House Ordos

Irulan's treatchury - still remeber Kailea Vernius? It was the same! Leto's ignorance, Paul's ignorance - that brings treatchury... never mary for love that's total crap!!! Man I hate Atreides 8)

[Acriku]

But remember, there are ear plugs that can be used. Also, I think BG "may" win in CQB but definitley not in OQB.

[Alexander_Ordos]

Imagine an army of BG in formation...mmmmm... What beauterful death commandos....total anihilation 8)

[Condorswarm]

I chose Chani. Cos in my opinion, shes pretty, strong, a warrior(I love warriors) and above all, she is cool.

I'm on God Emporer of Dune. Why did Frank Herbert miss 3000 years of history?