Chani or Irulan?

[Anathema]

Yeah and she threatened Duncan that she would tie his legs in a knot around his neck and according to Moneo she probably would have succeeded too :O.

My vote is still for Irulan.

[IxianMace]

Well actually it depends on what Alexander Ordos meant when he said that Siona was 'better' than both of them. Did he mean looks wise, intelligence, lethality? ::)

[Colonel_Worf]

Even Irulan wasn`t very good Bene Gesserit but she was still and had more skills than Chani, that was only good warrior.

More skills? Like ballet? :P

[IxianMace]

I think he meant skills like 'Prana Bindu' training and control of the voice.

[Sarahbones]

Irulan. She's more educated and cultured, and would be easier to hold a conversation with.

[Mad Rhetoric]

Chani rocks!Did you see her in the Dune 2000 movie?Hubahuba!

[Duke_Atreides]

Irulan. She's more educated and cultured, and would be easier to hold a conversation with.

EEHHhh???

What?? you can

[Anathema]

Chani was never in Dune2000- the games are based very thinly on the books.

Irulan would make a better wife then Chani.

[Mad Rhetoric]

Chani was never in Dune2000- the games are based very thinly on the books.

Irulan would make a better wife then Chani.

Whoops,I meant the movie by William Hurt. ::) ;D :)

[Duke_Atreides]

Irulan would make a better wife then Chani.

Why?

[Mad Rhetoric]

She wouldn't ;D ;D ;D ;)

[Taqwa11]

Well, this is an amazingly long thread. I'd have to pick Chani over Irulan. Irulan only wants Paul for status and to unite the houses. Chani, on the other hand, would die for Paul.

Now, for my own personal choice, though: I'd choose Murbella, the adopted Bene Gesserit. Why? Because she knows all those great sex tricks that totally enslave a man. She enslaved Duncan, after all. LOL. AND, she is a great fighter. I mean, what a life with her: Sex, then a martial arts lesson or two, sex . . .

[Sarahbones]

Actually my choice, for me, would be neither - I'd pick Feyd-Rautha and if he wasn't available, then a Sardaukar. But, if I were male: Irulan is Bene Gesserit trained; Chani isn't. Irulan is beautiful and well-educated; Chani, well, isn't.

Also, it would be very, very difficult to poison or drug Irulan (unlike Chani) and she is far less likely to die in childbirth (ditto). Best of all, she's an excellent writer. Can Chani even write her name?

[Duke_Atreides]

and she is far less likely to die in childbirth (ditto).

You have a point here, she must have sex first.

[Anathema]

Hehe :)

[NHJ BV]

Chani, I can get education and culture everywhere :)

[gunner154]

Chani was never in Dune2000- the games are based very thinly on the books.

Irulan would make a better wife then Chani.

Whoops,I meant the movie by William Hurt. ::) ;D :)

The show by William Hurt? No...that 6hr miniseries was NOT by William Hurt. I don't know who's the producer hehe, but William Hurt is the cast, he's Leto.

Feel free to correct me about who the producer is, just that I know that William Hurt acted as Leto.

[Andrew]

written and directed by John Harrison.

long live dune

[Alexander_Ordos]

Now I must say that Murbella is the best Dunegirl - FASTER-STRONGER ( in any aspect :) )-BETTER ;) Sheana is not bad but... ahh my vote goes for Murbella, though Irulan is better that Chani anyway :P