evilbaronatreides Posted January 4, 2002 Posted January 4, 2002 Alright this is whats going down: Einstein was fiddling with his Chronosphere and instead of punching a hole through time, he punched a hole through reality. At the same time, a novice Navigator was looking ahead in time and inadvertedly did the same thing. With two holes in the fabric of reality, they come togather, bridging two worlds: the world of Red Alert and the world of Dune. Both worlds find the other as invaders and the battle is set. Now who would win Emperor or Red Alert 2? (feel free to include any past units from CNC, Dune 2k, Tiberian Sun, etc)
Usul Posted January 4, 2002 Posted January 4, 2002 I've never played Emporer but ive played all the c and c games. the only units i can think of wich are superior in emporer are the sub house units otherwise I think migs, prisms, harriers, v3s, mirages,grizlys,ifvs,tanya,crazy ivans, devils tounges,longbows, cyborgs,teslas,mammoths,appocalpses,etc will easily conquer Dune
nemafakei Posted January 4, 2002 Posted January 4, 2002 Emp. The combined might of the Landsraad, the Fremen and the Sardaukar will easily crush the RA2 people.Remember: Shields are damn good against almost all RA2 weapons.
thomas Posted January 4, 2002 Posted January 4, 2002 RA2 would get its bum kicked by emp.remember deviators las guns.
evilbaronatreides Posted January 4, 2002 Author Posted January 4, 2002 Oh yeah i fogot to add: please post reasons and comparisons between units.
alphabeta4000 Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 ordos and atreides super weapons, remember that
Usul Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 yeh but in the games they don't use sheilds do they? Plus ra2 units have the cronosphere and the iron curtan. and in the games surly a lasgun would not destroy a unit outright so our tanks,etc would eaisily slaughter you.
Nyarlathotep Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 The missile tanks form the Harks are pretty fast a quiet accurate. When fired, they can easily avoid anything that comes their way. Another good unit: Devastator ! True, slow, but stick it under an advanced carryall and it'll be hard to beat.It's fire poweris  always deadly when it fires.And I even didn't start to mention the Mino's yet...As for Tanya and any other wanna be hero in RA2... The Sard's will take good care of her and any others. Especially elite Sard's...Fremen...well, let's ask some help from their friends the worms, shall we...There's no way anyone is going to concvince me that RA's would win...
nampigai Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 I agree, besides E:BFD is way better than RA2 Â ;D
Edric O Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 C&C units and weapons are MUCH more destructive. They would easily kick the Landsraad's @$$... and then Shai-Hulud would come and eat them all. ;D ;D ;D
Muai Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 C&C's story is much better then dune's..... Like in Emperor of Dune the name of all the characters is diffrent from the book!! If it is because it's later it can't be right 'cause the house Harkonnen was destroyed in the first games/books! ::)
s2 Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 E:BFD would kick the Ra2's "bum"anyday of the week. thats the bottom line. 8)
gunner154 Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 Titans VS MongeeseResults: Titans winFirepower greater. Accuracy better. Armour Better.Dust Scout VS Hum-VeeResults: Dust Scout WinsFirepower is great.Devil's Tongue VS Flame TankResults: Flame Tank Wins.Dual Flame ports. Excellent Armour.Overall Results:The Answers have been predicted. EBFD wins!
Edric O Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 Core Defender vs. anything you can throw at itresult: Core Defender wins! Nothing can stand up to that monster!Shai Hulud vs. Core Defenderresult: BURP!! ;D
Muai Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 Good try gunner154 but if u look on all the pages with the info abaut the units in E:BOD and C&C u will find out that it's all a lie! Try again ;D ! C&c RULES
nemafakei Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 There is no way to campare the two by comparing units, since all the damage, armour and speed is relative. Dust scout and humm-vee cannot compare, because there is nothing common to both worlds.Anyway, shields in Emp aren't proper shields. They can be taken out by tank shells and the like.
Nyarlathotep Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 I'll go with Edric O on this one...*BURP* ;D
Usul Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 exacly Nema so RA2 would win prisms beat anything in dune also you forgot the atomic bombs, demo trucks, terrorists and weather control as well as the cronosphere and iron curtian
alphabeta4000 Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 just shut up. there are good and bad points and the emperor atom bombs are better
alphabeta4000 Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 also emperor is father into the future. It doesn't really matter why doesn't a black hole just come a long
evilbaronatreides Posted January 5, 2002 Author Posted January 5, 2002 for the sake of arguement, lets say the timespace between the two doesn't matter
Gobalopper Posted January 5, 2002 Posted January 5, 2002 If the battle takes place on Arrakis then Emperor is the clear winner. But take away the Sandworms and the outcome becomes clouded...
alphabeta4000 Posted January 6, 2002 Posted January 6, 2002 well stuff it all! Advantages, disadvantages, crap more crap
Seth Posted January 6, 2002 Posted January 6, 2002 Yo we havent mentioned the Ixian Projectors that can clone thier units and also the infiltrators that can sneak in side the base. In infantry fights I would place my bets on the G.I.s but when it comes to tanks and mechs Dune rules and how would they bring their Naval fleet into the sand??And even if they fought their armor is not that advanced yet sand storms would tear them apart
Edric O Posted January 6, 2002 Posted January 6, 2002 Gob is right, it all depends on the setting. And not just because of Shai-Hulud... but because of the resources! The Landsraad can't harvest minerals or tiberium! And the C&C armies can't harvest spice...
Recommended Posts