Jump to content

Butlerian Jihad Reading Club

Mahdi

By Mahdi
in Duniverse

 Share

Recommended Posts

Timenn

Timenn

Posted
Posted

I couldn't resist reading it

I'm somewhere over halfway I guess. (You know that moment when... /Timenn is shut up by Namp)

But which part are we discussing right now?

I agree that Selim is rushed too much. And I think it's a annoying neat person. He just can't do anything wrong !

And I like Tio Holtzman, a different kind of hero, arrogant, I like that

But I think Xavier Harkonnen is a little bit too perfect, but Serena kicks ass

I like Vorian Atreides too, a nice and smart badguy :)

And the story is going well :)

Inhuien

Inhuien

Posted
Posted

Yep Timenn my BT Brother. Perhaps we can chat about any questions or plotholes? :)

Its not a plot hole as such, perhaps just an omission, But why do you think neither Paul nor LetoII make a mention of the Nasty ancestor(?)

Its a shame that the new books fall at this test, because its a good plot.

Acriku

Acriku

Posted
Posted

They might've been in his many many pages of notes. Believe me, he had a lot of notes on BT and Agamemnon is a major part of it, so it's likely that he was in his notes.

Duneguy

Duneguy

Posted
Posted

When Serena is pregnant and Erasmus(may have spelled wrong) slave, is it just me or does her flirtation with vorian PISS you guys off? maybe i will learn something in the latter chapters as im only on page 404...

Duneguy

Duneguy

Posted
Posted

[hide]Well so far i am at the part where that versilus is at arrakis and is eating a melange cake thingy.. so far in the book ive been alright.. but i have a few things that need to be cleared up...

The sorceresses blasts damage what? because didnt it say that it destroyed the titans brain.. wouldnt that fry the soldiers outside brains?

The Cognitors- can someone give me a definition.. i seem to be kinds confused on what they look like.

The shields-are they like the ones in the movie? trying to get a visual.

Is Lord Bludd in any of the other books.. cant seem to recognize the name.. maynbe i missed something...

Serena- seen somewhere talking about Tio being her Step Father.. whats all that about..

[/hide]

Acriku

Acriku

Posted
Posted

[hide] Yes it would, if they are in range, a reason would be something later on in the book where you aren't there yet.

Basically just jars with a brain floating in blue fluids?

Yeah pretty much.

Dunno.

No idea where you saw that, as far as I know there is no relation between Serena and Tio. [/hide]

Duneguy

Duneguy

Posted
Posted

i finished early this morning

and i may have a bit of inside info... can ya tell me

[hide] serena and Tio Holtzman made invented the first guild heighliner.. she was grasping the fact on folding space.. true?[/hide]

Dunenewt

Dunenewt

Posted
Posted

i finished early this morning

and i may have a bit of inside info... can ya tell me

[hide] serena and Tio Holtzman made invented the first guild heighliner.. she was grasping the fact on folding space.. true?[/hide]

[hide]No not Serena, it was Norma, Tio's assistant[/hide]

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.