Ninja_Sher Posted July 18, 2004 Posted July 18, 2004 Who do you think Ginaz mercanaries would fight like, the star war style, or the Ninja style or the Samurai Style?My guess is Ninja Style.
Vanguard3000 Posted July 18, 2004 Posted July 18, 2004 Ninja style, as in stealthiness, etc? I wouldn't think so. There are tons of scenes depicting them fighting in large numbers with little or so stealth.I would think they would use a medley of verious eatern and western martial art forms.
Ninja_Sher Posted July 18, 2004 Author Posted July 18, 2004 Ninja style, as in stealthiness, etc? I wouldn't think so. There are tons of scenes depicting them fighting in large numbers with little or so stealth.I would think they would use a medley of verious eatern and western martial art forms.Ninja Style is not invisiblity ( it is just a section though Nonase means invisible ), I meant the way one of them take on several of the enemies. Perhaps they fight like Jedi Knights in Star Wars.
Caid Ivik Posted July 18, 2004 Posted July 18, 2004 Eastern style of killing with one sudden swing would be impossible in world with shields. As Japanese never had material ones, duniverse energic shields are even more effective. I think they fence with sabres, most possibly oriental ones (like turkish or arabian), which are stronger than for example polish or cossack ones as in mass, but more dependant on hand. As knives, we can say.
Emperor Harkonnen Posted July 18, 2004 Posted July 18, 2004 Ninjas don't necessarily fight with the use of stealth. In the James Bond movie You Only Live Twice, ninjas attack the vulcanocrater in large numbers.but where in the books are the fighting style of Ginaz Mercenaries reffered to?
Vanguard3000 Posted July 18, 2004 Posted July 18, 2004 I would exactly call a James Bond flick as being the definitive resource on ninjas...Caid, I think Sher was referring to the Mercenaries from the BJ trilogy, in which they fought unshielded robots. I recall they largely abstained from using shields themselves. But they used just about any blade, including rapiers. I seem to recall the swords had sonic vibration generators in the hilt, to maximize cutting ability.
Hawat Posted July 18, 2004 Posted July 18, 2004 Ninjas were never trained to face strong enemies in direct combat. As trained assassins they would rely on a quick direct kill from behind. (Just my assumptions plus some infos from a martial arts trainer i know) My bet would be an eastern kung fu style (i don't refer to that kungfu from the movies, kungfu normally is used
Alexander_Ordos Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 I think they fight with long swords in a style close to the one we see in SW, Jedi lightsaber mastery ;)
Caid Ivik Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 How can you fight with a medieval long sword in a saber style?
exatreide Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 If anyone has seen kill bill volum one..The last scewne in the japanease hotel the big brawl..I sware I thought to my self.."Damn she must be a level 12 swordmaster." Then I caught my self and slaped me for being such a nerd..
Alexander_Ordos Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 Caid, I think sabers have nothing in common with lighsabers ;) The fact is that it's long and one-handed. And it is possible to figh rapidly with it, if you have appropriate skills, like knowing the best points of balance, etc...
TMA_1 Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 yeah darn kevin j probably took vibro blades from the starwars universe and put them into the ginaz arsinal.They obviously do not fight in any sort of eastern martial arts style. The reason being is that western sword arts are in themselves very complex unlike what a lot ofp eople think, and not only this but in the dune books the weapons mentioned are largely western. Because of this and the fact that no real eastern weapons are mentioned (some middle eastern weapons are mentioned but they arent related to far eastern kinds) tells me that they focus on western styles of fighting, added with new techniques. You can tell with the kinds of stances that are used that are western in approch, also how duncan fights and what weapons he uses. He also uses some more "blunt" and more militaristic rather than artful styles like the use of a small knife with a short sword.They were NOT eastern in their style of fighting.Also the ninja's did not use kung fu, that is silly. Certain families still hand down the oldschool styles of ninjutsu. This kind of style does not only encorperate martial arts, but healing remedies as well as alchemy and engineering. It was the art of life for early ninja's before they became mercinaries. They were gaurilla fighters. Their form of martial arts though is largely similar to things like kenjutsu that focuses on swordsmenship as well as joint locks, throws, low kicks and punches, as well as pressure points. It is not at all similar to kung fu. I studied martial arts in detail as I used to be really interested in it, I myself was in martial arts for awhile, both a japanese style and korean as well.
Alexander_Ordos Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 How do you know? Have you tried a lightsaber? ;DYou can tell from the movies, that they're long and straight...and we both know how a saber looks...
Hawat Posted July 19, 2004 Posted July 19, 2004 Also the ninja's did not use kung fu, that is silly. That's not what i said. That Kungfu part in my last post refers to the ginaz mercenaries and not to ninjas.
exatreide Posted July 20, 2004 Posted July 20, 2004 You can tell from the movies, that they're long and straight...and we both know how a saber looks...a saber is curved....
Emperor Harkonnen Posted July 20, 2004 Posted July 20, 2004 I think they use weapons such as crossbow in dune, and that is a western weapon. but where in the books are can one see that the swords are western?
TMA_1 Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 well one big place where you see that is in dune, when you see the sardaukar fighting, as well as duncan and others fighting. very western and mixed with a tad bit of middle eastern with the weapons.also at the beginning when gurney puts out the weapons for weapons practice, the books gives a list of some of the weapons shown, and almost all of them have western origins, none though that are far eastern. And this is the general theme of weapons that is through the whole series.
Wolf Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 The Ginaz fighters probably use a mix of styles -- taking the best from each discipline. It's probably a mix of Eastern style and form and Western speed and destructiveness. Ginaz fighters don't fight with the Eastern mentality of disarming opponents without killing them. In fact, its similar to the US Marine Corps goal of killing any man in seconds.Oddly enough, I once spoke to a Marine lieutenant who told me that the USMC hand-to-hand combat training is itself a mix of fighting styles from all over the world.
TMA_1 Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 hmm we disagree there wolf, I mean show me where it talks about eastern arts mixed into ginaz swordsmenship.the only place with definite eastern military arts are the bene gesserits and the honored matres, that is about it in my books, I dont see why people always have to put eastern martial arts into things like dune.
Hawat Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 I guessed it would be an eastern art, because eastern martial arts mainly teach to counter strength by being fluid like water (in a metaphorical way ;) ) and use the enemies momentum against him. Another principle is that your weapons are extensions of your hands. I think both principles are extremely helpful to fight something that is far superior in strength. (a machine for example).Im not very knowledgeable about western fighting styles, but i never heard about these principles thought in western art.
TMA_1 Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 hmm you should study the art of a double handed bastard or long sword, like a claymore. they are focused on that, and have manuals and even teachers that thought strategums and things about swordplay.
Hawat Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 *sigh* i would i've had the time to learn that properly.The aborted kungfu (precisely: chi-sim-vim-chung) study was enough.
TMA_1 Posted July 21, 2004 Posted July 21, 2004 yeah it is interesting stuff. I mean I could be wrong about this, but I just part ways with the preqeuls in this area. I think the martial arts of ginaz are western in approch. Not only that but after thosuands of years they have probably evolved into their own, not eastern or western but something totally new.
Recommended Posts