Jump to content

Do Humans Have a Soul? My argument follows:


Recommended Posts

Emp, in your post you had projected that the self-preservation instinct is stronger than the herd instinct

hmmmm...if i did, it is entirely not what I meant. I only meant to say that when an animal has differing impulses, it simply obeys the stronger. My illustration of the lion was to show that sometimes, self-preservation is dominant, other times it is not.

dogs are not self-aware, Ace. Dolphins and chimps are. dogs have intelligence, but that is not self-awareness.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess dogs are fairly intelligent, as far as animals go, but I don't find them very interesting. To me, they have no personalities. They just all run and bark at things, and wag their tail after you come home or whatever. Really the only intersting thing I see about dogs is their loyalty.

Cats, however, are very intersting IMO. I've lived with about the same number of dogs and cats my whole life (one at a time though), and I see definite personality traits in each of the cats, barely any, if any, in the dogs. The cats seem to build unique identities based on their childhood, similar to how humans do. Cats are also very intelligent animals, you can even easily train them to poop in the toilet!

I think all these types of traits can be explained, and they are all likely to be part of the structure of the brain, including chemical balances and society instincts. Take ants for example, they leave a trail of a chemical they produce that leads from the ant hill to the food, so that all the ants can follow the route to the food and take it back. Also, if they sense danger, they will leave a different chemical that tells all the ants to freak out and run run run. Are these ants tought to behave and react this way? Probably not. They're just programmed that way. The question is: How did they become this way, through evolution, or through an act of god?

I agree that studying animals would reveal much about who we really are, afterall there is lots of evidence that we came from monkies who lived near water, and it all makes sense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They have been known to communicate with eachother. And what qualifies you to say dolphins and chimps are self aware? Did they tell you? lol. I'm not aware of any chimp philosophers in the past. I'm not saying they aren't self aware, but there is no more proof of that then of whales.

If whales were so intelligent you are talking about, why they can't fly and why they senselessly die on beaches? Intelligent creature would find out how to prevent itself from i.e. dangerous steam. I think creative mind is something, what cannot be just "evolved".

Flying? Can you fly? Lol. As for why they don't build cities or tools, one word: dexterity. We have hands wich allowed us to build instruments and use our creativity, whales do not. As for the stream thing, I could point out examples where human individuals did things much more stupid (like when a bank robber actually fills in a withdrawl paper with his name when he demands money lol).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

because dolphins and chimps are the only creatures (that I know of) that can recognize themselves in a mirror. To any other creature- including dogs and cats, they think their reflection is another animal.

If you put a mark on a dolphins fin and had him swim in front of a giant mirror, he would see the mark in the mirror, and then try to find the mark on his own body. (this is actual experiments, btw).

Dolphins are so amazing, they will actually play in front of the mirror like a child playing on a television, where other animals would be frightened. they know themselves. this is the very definition of self-awareness.

dogs and cats are just too simple to be able to identify themselves. whales also

Link to comment
Share on other sites

from sciencenet.org

Cats see their reflection just as we do. Their eyes are similar to ours so there's no reason to expect them to see anything other than a reflection. However, how they interpret what they see is up for discussion. From their behaviour it would appear that they don't recognise the image as a reflection of themselves. Any animal that sees themselves in a mirror or window will approach their reflection as if it were another animal. Cats tend to approach and touch the nose of the reflection. They are clearly confused by the resulting movement of the reflection, but they never seem to work out that it is their reflection.

there are numerous expirements for this. its pretty empirical that cats cannot recognize themselves.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yes i see you are right, the cat does not think its another cat after the initial look. i have been researching it for the last 30 minutes. a cat gets confused and quickly loses interest, unable to "process" what it is seeing, never realizing it sees itself.

whales....not sure but i thought I read that they dont either.

thats why I asked if anyone could 'add' to the list of dolphins and chimps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

this is really amazing. i love dolphins

"In the series of late sham-markings that occurred after the first genuine marking, the dolphin began to respond differently by engaging in substantially more sham-directed behaviors at reflective surfaces than during the early sham-markings (4.4% vs. 0.3%, respectively). These late sham-markings were thus differentiated from the early sham-markings. Only after repeated exposure to being marked did the animal begin to use the mirror to investigate its body after being sham-marked. In the late sham-marking sessions, the dolphin oriented to make the appropriate area visible substantially more often than when early sham-marking had occurred. These results, therefore, suggest that, in the late sham-marking trials, the dolphin used the mirror to investigate the touched area to determine whether it was marked and, upon discovering no mark, abandoned further self-directed behaviors. This pattern of behavior made it difficult to interpret the subjects' responses to late sham-markings as "true shams" and, as a result, only one sham-marking was conducted in Phase 2. "

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.