Whispers of a Caladan sea Reviews

[Dunenewt]

So from the people who have read it what do you think?

I think it was great if a little odd

[TMA_1]

yeah I loved it. Neo really was the one that got me into it. I suggest for anybody who wants to know about it to talk to NEO and just IM him. he knows about it all. ;)

I thought it was actually kinda touching at the end. I could understand why the fremen were pretty freaked by the whole thing.lol

[Vanguard3000]

I thought it was quite good. It's an interesting idea, to base a story on the poor, doomed Atreides troops. I always wondered what it would have been like for them. I thought the ending was quite good, with a hint of mysticism, but not too farfetched.