Thopter was a video-based game though, wasn't it? If anyone was making money off the site where it was, that may have been the problem. I don't have the site attached to any form of financial benefit -- no memberships with commissions per sale of book/movie clubs like Amazon.com, Barnes and Noble or the ilk, no paid advertising, etc. This is just the printed word. I had a long discussion with him on the subject. His words were something along the lines of: As long as you aren't making money off it, there's not a problem. We were allowed to use the characters and quotes from the stories. I was also lead to believe that KJA was one half of the Herbert Partnership, the other being BH. At the time, he had one of their [Herbert LTD. Partnership] lawyers check out the site. He told me later, it was fine.